*The Rate My Graphic Thread*

[bounda]

Alright, we dont have a graphics forum here so i started this thread. All you have to do is:
Rate the image that was requested to be rated above you
Put in an image you wish to be rated (Optional)
Ratings are 0/10

Ill start.. i want my current sig rated.. made it myself 

[Kazbadan]

I would suggest the following ratings (see that it still be between 0-10...i am just adding some qualifications to numbers:
0- uhh?! what is that?! even a monster is more beautiful than that
1- very ugly! sorry to say but thats what i think
2- its ugly! but you can find worst
3- its not good, sorry to say, you need a lot of work
4-  a little bad, it needs some improvements
5- not bad...but not that good either, but its appealing
6- nice work, somewhat good, you are in the good way
7- Good for sure, you have soul for this!
8- Very good! not to far from perfecrion
9- An amazing image, i love it!
10-Excelent! A Masterpiece!

Ok i would give it a 7 i think - i am thinking on other 3d images that i saw, thats why i give it a 7 and not more,but you have a great work there, also the image is too small for seeing details. But i like it! nice

[Kazbadan]

its not that great i know, but i was an amateur when i done that...now i am even worst than that lol, because i dont try to learn anymore when 3dstudio max...i dont have time

[3588897]

I would give your image an 8. My reason would be that the background looks alot like some things I've seen through my telescope while looking at the galactic plane. And the planet looks like you were trying to give it at atmosphere which is rather hard to do whether your sketching it or drawing it in photoshop. Also nice work on the globular clusters in the background.

I don't have anything to be rated yet but I'll get something sketched tonight if it isn't too cold outside.

Nevermind. Scanner quit working and I can't draw anything good.

[Kazbadan]

thanks

[bounda]

i thought it looked excellent.. 8/10
/edit

its animated... rate it

[Kazbadan]

i just gave it a 7 because its too small for seeing more details, because in this view and at such size of course thats an excelent work! I am an amateur when compared to u!

Do u have more works to show?

[Woah]

That signature two posts up, I'll give an 8. Would be 9, but I don't like animated. It's not too small in my opinion, I hate big ones.

Here are some pixel art images I made when I was helping out with a pixel chat game, which never worked out. They are my first and only pixel art creations, I notice a lot of errors looking back. Almost half of them were quick drafts that I never fully made. They were all done only in Paint, about 2 years ago. I had no other graphic experience...

[jub jub]

I like the animated one. Looks like a ten to me!

[Jitenya]

My Sig. Rate that.

To the animated sig: 6 OR 10

You used a unique way to make you Background in the animation: Using filters on thet same image as the Foreground.
Points Gained: 3
You compressed the gif etremely carefullry, so that a high level of quality.
Points Gained: 7
You used an automatic animation (Blending) common in many gif animators. Not impressive.
Points Lost: 4

If I'm wrong about the automated script, you have my apologies, and you have your ten.

[bounda]

Of course i have more!
Flavor #1

Flavor #2

My First Smudges

<< This one is animated, look closely!
PLZ RATE

[bounda]

Update: I just now finished this one.. either it looks really sick.. or im smokin something.

[Rob]

Ahh mate, your anime ones are ok to kinda cool (5-7 for me mostly - hey, I've been spoiled on anime  ) - but that last one? Now thats properly original, really well done, and I love the effects you have employed - it all works really well. Think I'll give it a 9, cos I am stingy! OK OK maybe a 9.5 then.... 

[bounda]

Ahh mate, your anime ones are ok to kinda cool (5-7 for me mostly - hey, I've been spoiled on anime  ) - but that last one? Now thats properly original, really well done, and I love the effects you have employed - it all works really well. Think I'll give it a 9, cos I am stingy! OK OK maybe a 9.5 then.... 

thx
also ppl you forgot to rate the pixel images

That signature two posts up, I'll give an 8. Would be 9, but I don't like animated. It's not too small in my opinion, I hate big ones.

Here are some pixel art images I made when I was helping out with a pixel chat game, which never worked out. They are my first and only pixel art creations, I notice a lot of errors looking back. Almost half of them were quick drafts that I never fully made. They were all done only in Paint, about 2 years ago. I had no other graphic experience...

i give them a 7/10 cuz i know its kinda hard to do pixel art

[bounda]

I just finished another sig, but im not sure which one you guys think is best, so please tell me wat you would rate each of these:

(without final layer)

(final layer using soft light and wind)

(final layer using pin light)

also, ill be giving away one of these as a signature to a the forum member that claims it first in the request thread, but only choose one.

Rate