Hi RM,
I don't get paralyzed or have astral sight either. But I feel pretty sure that my OBE's are legit! (After all, I keep verifying them!)
Jeff and I have similar experiences and I think the way it differs from what you are trying is simply this - we allow our selves to drift off to sleep with the firm (and I mean FIRM, absolutely intent) intent to stay mentally awake. So we get that snap back thing going where eventually we snap back into a situation where the body is dead asleep. I seriously doubt I could get my body that dead asleep without falling asleep and snapping my awareness out of it.
I am not clear if others can achieve this sort of state without some falling asleep. Maybe they can. It sounds to me like you are trying to get there in a completely controlled manner, not letting your body go to sleep because you don't want to lose control and .... well....fall asleep!
I often (not always) know if I am going to succeed or not based on whether there is a voice in my mind telling me that I really should get a good night's sleep. That is, I rarely succeed if I am half hearted. The determination to stay mentally awake is key. And again, it's not that I DO stay mentally awake without any breaks in awareness, rather it is that I am intent on staying awake and so every time I drift off, my consciousness snaps me back.
(I always thought hypnogogic imagery was not something to engage in anymore than thoughts. I always thought that I should reset my intent every time i saw such imagery. Which means losing a bit of the trance. But I always figured that was part of the snapping back process.)
I can't address your other questions. A lot of Robert's most useful info is on the web, so I don't think that buying the book is necessarily the key. It's a great book, well written, and I recommend it. When you have more money.
For what it's worth, I have been grounded for the last twenty or so attempts; no approach is foolproof except maybe for someone with lots of experience or with a knack for it.
Patty
I don't get paralyzed or have astral sight either. But I feel pretty sure that my OBE's are legit! (After all, I keep verifying them!)
Jeff and I have similar experiences and I think the way it differs from what you are trying is simply this - we allow our selves to drift off to sleep with the firm (and I mean FIRM, absolutely intent) intent to stay mentally awake. So we get that snap back thing going where eventually we snap back into a situation where the body is dead asleep. I seriously doubt I could get my body that dead asleep without falling asleep and snapping my awareness out of it.
I am not clear if others can achieve this sort of state without some falling asleep. Maybe they can. It sounds to me like you are trying to get there in a completely controlled manner, not letting your body go to sleep because you don't want to lose control and .... well....fall asleep!
I often (not always) know if I am going to succeed or not based on whether there is a voice in my mind telling me that I really should get a good night's sleep. That is, I rarely succeed if I am half hearted. The determination to stay mentally awake is key. And again, it's not that I DO stay mentally awake without any breaks in awareness, rather it is that I am intent on staying awake and so every time I drift off, my consciousness snaps me back.
(I always thought hypnogogic imagery was not something to engage in anymore than thoughts. I always thought that I should reset my intent every time i saw such imagery. Which means losing a bit of the trance. But I always figured that was part of the snapping back process.)
I can't address your other questions. A lot of Robert's most useful info is on the web, so I don't think that buying the book is necessarily the key. It's a great book, well written, and I recommend it. When you have more money.
For what it's worth, I have been grounded for the last twenty or so attempts; no approach is foolproof except maybe for someone with lots of experience or with a knack for it.
Patty