Hi
I have 2 questions about noticing
1, I have read at several places that Frank describes "noticing" as an "exercise for beginners" or a "preliminary exercise before using a rundown". This confused me a bit because I thought that "noticing" (passively observe the blackness in front of my closed eyes and notice whatewer takes palce within) is an effective phasing tecnique and one can phase to F3 by using noticing only. Can someone tell me if I am right? Can I get to F3 by using noticing only?
2, When I do the noticing exercise, I observe the blacness in front of my closed eyes and notice whatever I see (light patterns, swirling shapes,...). When I see some more distinctive thing I sometimes think "What an interesting shape" or "what a nice colour" and things like that. This helps me keep my attention on noticing. Otherwise ( as Frank suggests) I do not get too curious and observe these things passively.
All in all, when I do the noticing exercise I do not keep my mind totally empty and allow myself to occasionaly comment on things. Is it all right to do the exercise this way? Or should I do it more like a mediattion when I try to keep my mind empty and passively observe the object of meditation (flow of breath, blacness in front of closed eyes) and do not comment on them? Thanks for answering
I have 2 questions about noticing
1, I have read at several places that Frank describes "noticing" as an "exercise for beginners" or a "preliminary exercise before using a rundown". This confused me a bit because I thought that "noticing" (passively observe the blackness in front of my closed eyes and notice whatewer takes palce within) is an effective phasing tecnique and one can phase to F3 by using noticing only. Can someone tell me if I am right? Can I get to F3 by using noticing only?
2, When I do the noticing exercise, I observe the blacness in front of my closed eyes and notice whatever I see (light patterns, swirling shapes,...). When I see some more distinctive thing I sometimes think "What an interesting shape" or "what a nice colour" and things like that. This helps me keep my attention on noticing. Otherwise ( as Frank suggests) I do not get too curious and observe these things passively.
All in all, when I do the noticing exercise I do not keep my mind totally empty and allow myself to occasionaly comment on things. Is it all right to do the exercise this way? Or should I do it more like a mediattion when I try to keep my mind empty and passively observe the object of meditation (flow of breath, blacness in front of closed eyes) and do not comment on them? Thanks for answering