I've been a user here for only a while, and few people will have heard of me, but that's because I mostly read, rarely post. Most (beginner-) questions have been asked already anyway.
I have not voted yet. I don't intend to vote, because I think the options are too limited.
Sygmoral
I have not voted yet. I don't intend to vote, because I think the options are too limited.
- If there is to be a new forum, then it should definitely be viewable to the world, regardless of the way the users can obtain allowance to post into that forum.
- Having to pay to post in the new forum is kind of 'not fair'... I would agree that AP could very well use the money, for whatever purpose that would benifit its users, but it is not good to put a lign between members that can pay and those that can't.
Therefore, my suggestion is to start with a number of obviously advanced users (for free). The moderators could make up this list. After that, any member that wants to post in the advanced forum must ask to be considered, and then everyone that is already member in the new forum should (anonymously) vote whether this person is worth to be allowed. The reasons why somebody should be allowed, should be their posts in -this- forum, that Advanced Users can review.
Advanced Users should also not be afraid to vote 'no'. I really think the Advanced Forum should be some sort of an Elite group (in my eyes at least).
This way, and only in this way I think, can you group the more advanced people.
About the money; there should really be some sort of a donation possibility. I would gladly donate like $25, but wouldn't pay $10 for the forum because I'm only a beginner anyway.
Beginners can have $10. Anyone can have $10. Therefore, in this way, there will always be 'unworthwhile' members in the Advanced Forum. ==> membership should be DESERVED, not bought!
Sygmoral