Well, that's funny. The two people who had "success" with this both had 1 post and terrible grammar.
Makes you wonder?
Makes you wonder?
Welcome to the Astral Pulse 2.0!
If you're looking for your Journal, I've created a central sub forum for them here: https://www.astralpulse.com/forums/dream-and-projection-journals/
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.
Show posts MenuQuote from: Psilibus on June 11, 2010, 07:13:26Somewhat success. There is one in my room, but this is not that uncommon. Plausable proof? Very good though! I appreciate you trying! Please feel free to try again!
The object is a globe.
Quote from: jub jub on June 09, 2010, 14:59:08Lol nope not that either. Did you see me at all?
It seemed pretty straight forward to me.
There was one other thing that I noticed but I thought for sure you wouldn't have one on your desk and that was, a model of an oil drilling platform. Must be all the TV I'm watching.
Quote from: jub jub on June 09, 2010, 08:12:17Not at all, but thanks for trying!
OK, I went to your desk a total of three times last night. Each time I observed something different (go figure). What I saw:
Trip one - Pet Turtle
Trip two - A stuffed cat
Trip three - A Jake Sully Avatar action figure
So, was I close?![]()
Quote from: AstralBeginnings on June 09, 2010, 01:13:01It was the first sentence, not misleading
Then the title of this post is a bit misleading then. To verify something (OBE Verification Test) is to prove it. It should say "Object on Desk Verification Test"
Quote from: Jay12341235 on June 06, 2010, 20:44:02
Hello, I have a simple experiment in mind. It is to see whether or not you can visit a certain place and tell me what is there. This will prove, if done correctly, that:
B. You visit real places during astral projections/out of body experiences.
Quote from: phxsun on June 08, 2010, 09:02:09That does not have anything to do with this experiment at all. The experiment is to see if someone can view on object that is really there while projecting/OBEing. This is not to prove whether ghosts exists or astral projecting or OBEs exist.
I have a friend who has a little boy spirit from the 1800 that stays with her all the time. Other people have asked her who the little boy is that is with her in her car, so others can see him as well. He has told her that he plans on staying with her until she is ready to go with him. I think that is prof enough for me.
daniel
Quote from: AstralBeginnings on June 08, 2010, 00:48:43The experiment asks for someone to try it, not to theorize why it would be incorrect. That is the point of the experiment. I would like it if you, or anyone, gave it a try just to give a shot at it. There's no punishment for being wrong, but we get nowhere if all we do is try to disprove it with words.
I think I disagree with this. Why "technically" should you get to where you need to be? You say subconsciously I already know where Jay lives - how is this the case? These questions arent a "bitchy" response or anything, I genuinely dont know the answers and would like to hear your views.
Also, I read somewhere (cant remember where but may also be Robert Peterson) that alot of scientifically tested verifications fail to provide accurate results - one example was a guy who had to verify an object in an adjoining room (an American Flag). When he returned back to body, he drew a rectangle with a box in the top left. Obviously this represents the US flag which is a successful verification, however the US flag is one of the most recognizable visual objects in the world, yet this experienced projector could not "see" it clearly and did not know it was the USA flag. This shows the differences between physical and non-physical perception.
And lets not forget, when we have an OBE/AP we do not use physical eyes, and therefore our vision is not limited to the specific workings of a physical eye. When we use physical eyes to look at something, the same thing happens EVERY time - light travels, hits the eye, the eye submits signal to the brain etc etc - like a machine. What happens when we view something with non-physical eyes? Nobody knows! There is nothing physical to dissect and work out how it works. So even if we do get into the exact location (which I still dont think would be easy unless its a person or a location we know), the test would still "fail" because the object seen may appear different to physical reality.
Still, its a great test and I hope people do try it - I just wouldnt count this kind of thing as "proof" because either a right or a wrong guess could be achieved in many ways and even a wrong guess could actually be a successful verification but with the object perceived differently, such as the USA flag example above.
Quote from: jub jub on June 07, 2010, 13:06:11You are very welcome. Thanks for your response!
That's a good write-up! Thanks for posting!
Quote from: AstralBeginnings on June 07, 2010, 02:49:57I'm not really bent on it, it's just interesting. Even though the points you made were very good, it'd still be cool if some of you tried it.
I have indeed traveled to a real place when OBE and I have also verified - I do not need anyone to believe me as the experience itself is verification enough for ME. But like I said, while these kind of experiments are interesting, I think it is highly unlikely that simply by posting a picture of a desk which could be anywhere, that anyone will have success projecting there.
In Robert Petersons book "Lessons out of the body" he states the following which I have summarised into the problem headings without going into the actual text. He uses an example where "John" but lets call him "Jay" asks him via email to verify an object in Jay's home. The words in brackets are mine and not from the book:
*Problem 1 - I dont know where Jay lives
*Problem 2 - (Lets say Jay lives in Cleveland) How do I get to Cleveland (walk, run, fly, Teleport)?
*Problem 3 - (Lets say I decide to fly) How do I find Cleveland?
*Problem 4 - (Lets say I know Cleveland is 1000 miles west) How do I find Jay's street in Cleveland?
*Problem 5 - (Lets see I have Jays address) How do I find Jays exact House?
*Problem 6 - (Lets say I find Jays house) How do I find the desk inside the house?
*Problem 7 - There are differences between physical reality and the reality experiences when out of body (ill mention this more in a second)
*Problem 8 - If I find the desk and observe it, I am depending on memory alone (cannot takes notes) which could distort what really is seen
*Problem 9 - What constitutes as "proof"? (how can you REALLY verify the truth? It could be a guess or some other form of ESP etc)
Going back to problem 7 - which I think is the main problem assuming all of the other preceding ones are resolved - is that (IMO) when you are out of body, you are not wandering around the actual physical world, but a very close "replica" operating on a different level of vibration or consciousness. This introduces reality fluctuations meaning that if the object you want me to view is a red cup, I may see it as a green vase. This doesnt mean the experiment has failed, but highlights the problem with the differences of physical (stable) and non-physical (fluid) realities and the issue of obtaining proof.
Personally, I do (or did) understand the need for verification so I totally understand your reasons for this "test" however once you experience an OBE (you may or may not have) then the whole verification thing is meaningless because you will KNOW.
I suggest, if you are hell bent on verification, to get it yourself by conducting your own experiment in your own locale. At the end of the day, who do you need to prove this to? Only yourself.
To highlight this, I going to literally guess at the object - if I am right then you can see "proof" is silly because it was just a guess. If I am wrong, well it doesnt matter because the chances of me being wrong but also succeeding in the test are also high based on the above problems, especially reality fluctuations.
I think [rubs temples and hums]...[more humming]...[oh an itch, scratch my balls]...[more humming]....AHA!! Its a blue phone. Or is it a plant?
"
Quote from: AstralBeginnings on June 06, 2010, 23:00:28
There are all sorts of issues attached with traveling to a specific location, and I personally think it helps if you actually know the place and in particularly the feel of the place / person you want to visit. I doubt very much anyone can just say "take me that there desk from the picture" and will be in your home. There are probably 100's of thousands of desks like that one, so why would you be taken to yours specifically?
I'm all for experiments such as this one, however when a random internet bod asks people to verify the reality of OBE by going to his house, the chances of success are (IMHO) ridiculously small. Verification tests are best done in closer locales and/or which the OBEer knows well so they can actually find the thing! For example I did a verification test in my own home with my wife verifying it - I know where I live so this was a good start.
Besides, if you want to verify OBE realness, practice and have one yourself. I promise you will never doubt their realness again.
Quote from: Xanth on June 06, 2010, 21:57:38Lol that sounds good. If anyone would like to try, go right ahead.
Actually, we have two separate people with two separate "objects".
Bacterio's exists solely on Astral Pulse Island.
Graytraveler's object, I believe is held within his home and is a tangible physical reality object.
However, there's little reason we couldn't add a third object into the mix!
~Ryan
Quote from: personalreality on June 06, 2010, 21:13:30I just read it now. This is different, this is an actual physical object to be verified in the real world. I believe the "API" thread is about something formed by thought.
Have you seen the "API Experiment" thread?