Lucid Dream or Astral Project?

[nevon91]

hello there,i have tryed over 10 time lucid dream...i list down the feeling

1.in the middle of dream suddenly i relize i am dreaming and then my screen turn to very clear i can control my hands and leg and when i walking i can feel the ground but it only last 1minute and i wake up in real life,after i wake up in real life i saw spiral light on the blackness screen(close eye) and then i can feel my dream hand moving but it only last 5-10 sec

2.this is the 2nd situation.. i directly enter a unknown world without dreaming ,my screen are semi clear and i can't control my hand and leg and i  see people walking around .. when i command the person walk to me and she did really walk to me LOL and then this world is weird..when i think anything and it happen anything..i can do anything in this world..this dream last around 10minute!

i am quite confuse..either i am in luciding dreaming or astral project

[Pauli2]

When you are in LD, request:

"Awareness now!"

Then wait a moment to observe if your surroundings change and stabilizes. If not, repeat your request. Hopefully this will result in the LD turning into an OBE.

[Xanth]

hello there,i have tryed over 10 time lucid dream...i list down the feeling

1.in the middle of dream suddenly i relize i am dreaming and then my screen turn to very clear i can control my hands and leg and when i walking i can feel the ground but it only last 1minute and i wake up in real life,after i wake up in real life i saw spiral light on the blackness screen(close eye) and then i can feel my dream hand moving but it only last 5-10 sec

2.this is the 2nd situation.. i directly enter a unknown world without dreaming ,my screen are semi clear and i can't control my hand and leg and i  see people walking around .. when i command the person walk to me and she did really walk to me LOL and then this world is weird..when i think anything and it happen anything..i can do anything in this world..this dream last around 10minute!

i am quite confuse..either i am in luciding dreaming or astral project

At the very least, the underlined and bolded part of your statement means it was a "Lucid Dream" (or as I call it a Lucid Awareness Experience).

For myself, to classify it as an "Astral Projection" (or as I call it an Astral Awareness Experience), you would have to be in the non-physical (in this case, the dream) and have what I refer to as a "waking awareness".  A waking awareness is what you have right now, you're wide awake with the full knowledge of who you are, what you are and where you are... with all memories therein.  If you have that WHILE you're in the non-physical, then you're having an Astral Awareness Experience. 

But yes, at the VERY LEAST, you had a Lucid Awareness Experience.  Congrats. 

[Greytraveller]

Hallo nevon
I would classify the first experience as a lucid dream. This is because, as you wrote,

in the middle of dream suddenly i relize i am dreaming

You see that is what a lucid dream is. It is when you are in a dream And you realize that you are dreaming.

However I am not sure what the second experience was. I am confused when you wrote,

i directly enter a unknown world without dreaming

Did you mean that you were sure that it was Not a dream??
Or did you mean that you were unsure as it could have been a dream or it could have been an OBE??
Also please explain what you meant by "screen" when you wrote,

my screen are semi clear and i can't control my hand and leg dreaming

Regards 
Grey