Debating Christianity

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Beth

The following post was relocated to this thread from another thread by the moderator:

Narrow Path
Silver Member
USA
126 Posts
Posted - 14 September 2003 :  00:46:25                
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

quote:
Standing but a step from His heavenly throne, Christ gave the commission to His disciples. "All power is given unto Me in heaven and in earth," He said. "Go ye therefore, and teach all nations." "Go ye into all the world, and preach the gospel to every creature." Mark 16:15. Again and again the words were repeated, that the disciples might grasp their significance.PREACH THE WORD, GOD'S WORD AND NOT MAN'S VERSION OF IT. Upon all the inhabitants of the earth, high and low, rich and poor, was the light of heaven to shine in clear, strong rays. The disciples were to be colaborers with their Redeemer in the work of saving the world.

The commission had been given to the twelve when Christ met with them in the upper chamber; but it was now to be given to a larger number. At the meeting on a mountain in Galilee, all the believers who could be called together were assembled. Of this meeting Christ Himself, before His death, had designated the time and place. The angel at the tomb reminded the disciples of His promise to meet them in Galilee. The promise was repeated to the believers who were gathered at Jerusalem during the Passover week, and through them it reached many lonely ones who were mourning the death of their Lord. With intense interest all looked forward to the interview. They made their way to the place of meeting by circuitous routes, coming in from every direction, to avoid exciting the suspicion of the jealous Jews. With wondering hearts they came, talking earnestly together of the news that had reached them concerning Christ.

At the time appointed, about five hundred believers were collected in little knots on the mountainside, eager to learn all that could be learned from those who had seen Christ since His resurrection. From group to group the disciples passed, telling all they had seen and heard of Jesus, and reasoning from the Scriptures as He had done with them. Thomas recounted the story of his unbelief, and told how his doubts had been swept away. Suddenly Jesus stood among them. No one could tell whence or how He came. Many who were present had never before seen Him; but in His hands and feet they beheld the marks of the crucifixion; His countenance was as the face of God, and when they saw Him, they worshiped Him.
But some doubted. So it will always be. There are those who find it hard to exercise faith, and they place themselves on the doubting side. These lose much because of their unbelief.

This was the only interview that Jesus had with many of the believers after His resurrection. He came and spoke to them saying, "All power is given unto Me in heaven and in earth." The disciples had worshiped Him before He spoke, but His words, falling from lips that had been closed in death, thrilled them with peculiar power. He was now the risen Saviour. Many of them had seen Him exercise His power in healing the sick and controlling satanic agencies. They believed that He possessed power to set up His kingdom at Jerusalem, power to quell all opposition, power over the elements of nature. He had stilled the angry waters; He had walked upon the white-crested billows; He had raised the dead to life. Now He declared that "all power" was given to Him. His words carried the minds of His hearers above earthly and temporal things to the heavenly and eternal. They were lifted to the highest conception of His dignity and glory.

Christ's words on the mountainside were the announcement that His sacrifice in behalf of man was full and complete. The conditions of the atonement had been fulfilled; the work for which He came to this world had been accomplished. He was on His way to the throne of God, to be honored by angels, principalities, and powers. He had entered upon His mediatorial work. Clothed with boundless authority, He gave His commission to the disciples: "Go ye therefore, and teach all nations," "baptizing them into the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit: teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I commanded you: and lo, I am with you always, even unto the end of the world." Matt. 28:19, 20, R. V.

The Jewish people had been made the depositaries of sacred truth; but Pharisaism had made them the most exclusive, the most bigoted, of
all the human race. Everything about the priests and rulers--their dress, customs, ceremonies, traditions--made them unfit to be the light of the world. They looked upon themselves, the Jewish nation, as the world. But Christ commissioned His disciples to proclaim a faith and worship that would have in it nothing of caste or country, a faith that would be adapted to all peoples, all nations, all classes of men.

Before leaving His disciples, Christ plainly stated the nature of His kingdom. He called to their minds what He had previously told them concerning it. He declared that it was not His purpose to establish in this world a temporal, but a spiritual kingdom. He was not to reign as an earthly king on David's throne. Again He opened to them the Scriptures, showing that all He had passed through had been ordained in heaven, in the councils between the Father and Himself. All had been foretold by men inspired by the Holy Spirit. He said, You see that all I have revealed to you concerning My rejection as the Messiah has come to pass. All I have said in regard to the humiliation I should endure and the death I should die, has been verified. On the third day I rose again. Search the Scriptures more diligently, and you will see that in all these things the specifications of prophecy concerning Me have been fulfilled.

It is critical to understand the importance of the Word and how it should be interpreted. Do not allow those that are in ignorance to decieve you into believing the resurrection of Christ was used as a "secret" or "hidden" message.

Stick to the sound doctrine and reject the worldview.


*******************************************************************
[this post was moved in its entirety]
Beth
Become a Critical Thinker!
"Ignorance is the greatest of all sins."
                   --Origen of Alexandria

Beth

The following post was relocated to this thread from another thread by the moderator:

Narrow Path
Silver Member
USA
126 Posts
Posted - 16 September 2003 :  00:51:59                
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

quote:
What the Gospel of Thomas relates as well as other Gnostic text.

1. Belief in "sercret" knowledge only bestowed upon the elite.
2. No belief in the physical resurrection of Christ but rather it being "symbolic".
3. Whoever achieves gnosis become no longer a Christian but a Christ.
4. Belief in a femine Divine power that supercedes God the Father.
5. Belief that the God of the OT is flawed and actually imperfect. Which leads to the conclusion that sin is a result of God and not man's choice.
6. Belief in many "gods".
7. Various panthiestic influences are detected especially in the Gospel of Mary.

Does not really fit in with the Monothiestic view huh?


*******************************************************************
[this post was moved in its entirety]
Beth
Become a Critical Thinker!
"Ignorance is the greatest of all sins."
                   --Origen of Alexandria

Beth

The following post was relocated to this thread from another thread by the moderator:

Tab
Silver Member
USA
193 Posts
Posted - 16 September 2003 :  01:12:06                  
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by Narrow Path


Does not really fit in with the Monothiestic view huh?

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Monotheism is a joke. Do you really think it makes a difference if you worship one single consumate deity or several deities? The two are very very similar in concept and they both promote the anthropomorphic concept of God(s) as a deity. The real opposite of mono/polytheism is belief in the nonanthropomorphic god. There's a real difference in thought.

Anyway that wasn't what I wanted to make a point of in this post.


quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Belief that the God of the OT is flawed and actually imperfect. Which leads to the conclusion that sin is a result of God and not man's choice.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Think about this just for one second. God is a supposedly all knowing deity. Yet, he created Adam and gave him the choice to eat of the fruit. As he is all knowing, he surely forsaw adam's partaking of the fruit, and therefore created him merely so that adam could disobey him and sin. First of all good job God. Second of all in that light, God created man so that he could sin - fall, and then return. Why would God do this? Wtf was god thinking? He created man so that man could separate from God and through that separation, realize what man was. Thus the only purpose of man is to realize God and rebecome one with him.
Sounds a lot like the concept of the one substance splitting into differentiation in order for it to realize and rebecome itself. So, either God was incredibly stupid, or he had something larger in mind.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ph34r the sumomo

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Edited by - Tab on 16 September 2003 01:13:21



****************************************************************
[this post was moved in its entirety--Beth]

Become a Critical Thinker!
"Ignorance is the greatest of all sins."
                   --Origen of Alexandria

Beth

The following post was relocated to this thread from another thread by the moderator:

Originally written by:
Narrow Path
Silver Member
USA
126 Posts


quote:
Posted - 16 September 2003 :  01:31:50                
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The wisdom of God is foolish to the wise.

COunt your blessings that he is giving us a second chance.

And about the polythiesm.........

14 Do not worship any other god, for the LORD , whose name is Jealous, is a jealous God.

Gnostic thought is WWWWWWAAAAAAAYYYYYYY off of what the Bible is teaching. It is not too hard to see that.



****************************************************************
[this post was moved in its entirety--Beth]
Become a Critical Thinker!
"Ignorance is the greatest of all sins."
                   --Origen of Alexandria

Beth

The following post was relocated to this thread from another thread by the moderator:


Originally written by:
Tab
Silver Member
USA
193 Posts

quote:
Posted - 16 September 2003 :  02:01:41                  
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by Narrow Path

God is foolish to the wise.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



agreed

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ph34r the sumomo


[this post was moved in its entirety--Beth]
Become a Critical Thinker!
"Ignorance is the greatest of all sins."
                   --Origen of Alexandria

Beth

The following post was relocated to this thread from another thread by the moderator:

Originally written by:
Beth
USA
quote:
Posted - 16 September 2003 :  05:39:41                
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Narrowpath:

Instead of asking you once again to please stay in your own threads...

I will offer you some more scripture (since you seem to prefer this method.)

It is also MY prayer for tonight:

II Corinthians 12:7-10
7 To keep me from becoming conceited because of these surpassingly great revelations, there was given me a thorn in my flesh, a messenger of Satan, to torment me. 8Three times I pleaded with the Lord to take it away from me. 9But he said to me, "My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness." Therefore I will boast all the more gladly about my weaknesses, so that Christ's power may rest on me. 10That is why, for Christ's sake, I delight in weaknesses, in insults, in hardships, in persecutions, in difficulties. For when I am weak, then I am strong.


Narrowpath...You have made me very tired and weak--but as Christ would have it--this has made me strong!

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------




[this post was moved in its entirety--Beth]
Become a Critical Thinker!
"Ignorance is the greatest of all sins."
                   --Origen of Alexandria

Beth

The following post was relocated to this thread from another thread by the moderator:

Originally written by:
Narrow Path
Silver Member
USA
126 Posts
quote:
Posted - 16 September 2003 :  23:32:27                
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Beth,

I have put down what the Gnostics believe. Please point out where I have mislead people.

Here is the list again.

What the Gospel of Thomas relates as well as other Gnostic text.

1. Belief in "sercret" knowledge only bestowed upon the elite.
2. No belief in the physical resurrection of Christ but rather it being "symbolic".
3. Whoever achieves gnosis become no longer a Christian but a Christ.
4. Belief in a femine Divine power that supercedes God the Father.
5. Belief that the God of the OT is flawed and actually imperfect. Which leads to the conclusion that sin is a result of God and not man's choice.
6. Belief in many "gods".
7. Various panthiestic influences are detected especially in the Gospel of Mary.

By the Way you quote a lot of scripture and say you have a relationship with Christ but I dont see how you miss the fact that IF YOU DO NOT BELIEVE IN THE WORK OF THE CROSS YOU ARE NOT A DISCIPLE AT ALL!!

Please post any scripture that says otherwise. That the cross was a bunch of bull and not the whole point of the Bible and the time Jesus spent here. It is pretty in your face if you look.



[this post was moved in its entirety--Beth]
Become a Critical Thinker!
"Ignorance is the greatest of all sins."
                   --Origen of Alexandria

Beth

The following post was relocated to this thread from another thread by the moderator:

Originally written by:
Tab
Silver Member
USA
193 Posts
quote:
Posted - 17 September 2003 :  01:47:04                  
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Well the whole of the christian dogma crumbles at simple logic, but I won't go into why God's big historical plan makes no sense right now, I'm tired of being so smart and cool.

I will say though that you've missed the whole meaning of the cross. First of all the cross is the archaic symbol of our material earth existance. Jesus, the Buddha, all the great initiates and divulgers of wisdom who have reached that level, have been crucified. Christ was nailed to the cross to save us - I.E. he purposefully returned to our world when he could have advanced far beyond, in order to divulge the wisdom of the Gods to us. There is an entire allegorical craft behind the crucifiction of Jesus in that. You should look it up, after all, thou should know thy god. :]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ph34r the sumomo



[this post was moved in its entirety--Beth]
Become a Critical Thinker!
"Ignorance is the greatest of all sins."
                   --Origen of Alexandria

Beth

The following post was relocated to this thread from another thread by the moderator:

Originally written by:
Makaveli
Active Member
USA
59 Posts
quote:
Posted - 17 September 2003 :  02:02:21                
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Narrow Path,

I don't know too much about gnostics but from the looks of it and given your past posts you are probably completley misrepresenting thier views, so hopefully someone who knows more about this can make that more clear.

I was just reading a little about gnostic christianity at: www.gnosticchristianity.com

One thing that you should pay attention to from that is it was talking about being nonjudgmental. Though asking you to consider being nonjudmental is probably going too far.


quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. No belief in the physical resurrection of Christ but rather it being "symbolic".
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



From the way the bible is written the stories look more symbolic even though some may have happened. If it were to be taken literally instead of symbolicly then there shouldn't be so many contradictions and errors. For instance with the story of Noah's Ark, it would be physically impossible to keep 2 of all animals plus enough food for them for that amount of time.




[this post was moved in its entirety--Beth]
Become a Critical Thinker!
"Ignorance is the greatest of all sins."
                   --Origen of Alexandria

Beth

The following post was relocated to this thread from another thread by the moderator:

Originally written by:
Narrow Path
Silver Member
USA
127 Posts
quote:
Posted - 17 September 2003 :  06:32:13                
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

John, Paul, Peter are all very clear on the issue that it was a physical resurrection.

If you want to find the Divine within go into the woods for a couple weeks, fast and do some ayahuasca.

Than you will see what "Gnosis" is all about.

But if you just want to find things the easy way stick to the Word.



[this post was moved in its entirety--Beth]
Become a Critical Thinker!
"Ignorance is the greatest of all sins."
                   --Origen of Alexandria

Narrow Path

Uhhhhhhhhhhh,

Is not what was wrote here the whole purpose of DEBATE or am I off here?

Are you a member of the ACLU Beth?[stricken by moderator]

Beth

Narrowpath,

THIS THREAD IS A DEBATE THREAD.

The threads that these posts were moved from, were NOT debate threads--they were DISCUSSION threads.  That it NOT the same thing.

Overall, this is not A DEBATE BOARD.  This is a MESSAGE BOARD designed to form discussions and explore ideas on A GREAT MANY TOPICS--not just Modern Day Christian views.  I am moving all adversarial posts to this thread in order to keep the other threads clean and open for discussion and exploration.

Be very careful Narrowpath, you are on very thin ice.

Religion Forum Moderator,
Beth
Become a Critical Thinker!
"Ignorance is the greatest of all sins."
                   --Origen of Alexandria

Tisha

Narrow Mind, I am taking off the Moderator hat, and my gloves, and expressing myself as a regular Astralpulse member for the benefit of all:

This is not a "Debate Forum."  Mr. Robert Bruce developed this website to be a forum for reasoned, thoughtful discussion. The moderators, along with many kind Astralpulse members, have been TRYING to help you understand the difference between discussion, debate, and the obnoxious, one-sided expression of fanatical beliefs. You're obviously an adult, but you just don't seem to get it.  I'm starting to worry that the drugs have permanently destroyed your ability to reason.  By now you ought to understand that you will not convert a single, blessed human being on these boards.  But you keep on banging your head against a brick wall.What's the definition of insanity?  Continuing to do the same thing, with the expectation of different results.  

The moderators are at their wits end with you. They've tried just about everything and are at the end of their rope. Their final approach before banning you completely is to manage this Forum so that the other 30,000+ Astralpulse members may engage in reasoned discussion without being disturbed by your obnoxious proselytizing.  

CONCLUSION: If folks want to come to this thread and debate you, that's just hunky-dory, and their choice.  The rest would much rather move on to more productive topics.  As for me, I'm putting my Moderator hat and my black opera gloves and returning to the Magic section to manage the heathens.

Tisha

Beth

This thread is for "Debating Christianity."  Knock yourselves out![:D]

[Posts made in other threads where an inappropriate debate begins, may also be moved into this thread by the moderator.  Such posts will be noted as such.]

Peace,
Beth
Become a Critical Thinker!
"Ignorance is the greatest of all sins."
                   --Origen of Alexandria